As part of a settlement announced earlier today, the Joplin R-8 School District will have to pay its former electrical contractor on the Joplin High School project $2.5 million by Tuesday, November 1.
Each side in the lawsuit, which was initially filed in 2015, will handle its own court costs, attorney fees, expert witness fees, and expenses.
At this point, the district has paid at least $1,070,723.07
The wording of the agreement is printed below:
SETTLEMENT AND RELEASE AGREEMENT
This Settlement and Release Agreement (“Agreement”) is entered into effective as of
September 27, 2016, by and among Joplin Schools, P1 Group, Inc. (“P1 Group”) and Universal
Construction Company, Inc. (“UCC”) (collectively referred to as the “Parties”):
WHEREAS, the Joplin Schools and P1 Group entered into a written contract dated
February 5, 2013 (the “Contract”) relating to construction of the new Joplin High School and the
Franklin Tech Center (the “Project”);
WHEREAS, on March 30, 2015, Joplin Schools filed a lawsuit in the United States
District Court for the Western District of Missouri, Southwestern Division, Case No. 3:15-CV-
05026-DGK (the “Lawsuit”);
WHEREAS, in the Lawsuit, Joplin Schools asserted claims against P1 Group, P1 Group
asserted counterclaims against Joplin Schools, and P1 Group also asserted claims against UCC as
a Third-Party Defendant;
WHEREAS, the Parties have reached an agreement to fully and finally settle and resolve
all claims and disputes between them as set out in greater detail below.
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual promises set forth herein, and
other good and valuable consideration the sufficiency of which is acknowledged, the Parties
agree as follows:
1. Payment by Joplin Schools. Joplin Schools shall pay to P1 Group the total
amount of Two Million Five Hundred Thousand Dollars and Zero Cents
($2,500,000.00) (the “Joplin Schools Payment”). The Joplin Schools Payment
shall be made on or before November 1, 2016. The payment shall be made by
wire transfer if technically feasible. P1 Group will provide wire instructions to
counsel for Joplin Schools by October 1, 2016.
2. Payment by UCC. UCC shall pay to P1 Group the entire unused balance of
UCC’s declining limits insurance policy. UCC represents that this balance is not
less than Seven Hundred Seventy-Five Thousand Dollars ($775,000.00) (the
“UCC Payment”). UCC shall provide an accounting, in terms of total legal fees
and total third party charges by vendor, against the policy to P1 Group on or
before October 10, 2016, with P1 Group reserving the right to make a reasonable
request for backup as to third party charges by vendor. UCC shall comply with
any such reasonable request. The UCC Payment shall be made on or before
November 1, 2016. The payment shall be made by wire transfer if technically
feasible. P1 Group will provide wire instructions to counsel for UCC by October
1, 2016.
3. Mutual Release. The Parties waive and release any and all claims of any kind or
nature they have, may have, or could hereafter have against any of the other
Parties hereto, including the Joplin Schools Board of Education, its members, and
the Parties’ respective employees, agents, representatives, insurers, attorneys and
predecessors and successors in interest, relating to or arising out of
(i) P1 Group’s
work on the Project,
(ii) the Contract and any other contracts between P1 Group and Joplin Schools for the Project,
(iii) the claims and defenses of Joplin Schools,
P1 Group and UCC related to the Project, and (iv) the Lawsuit, whether or not
such claims or defenses were asserted in the Lawsuit. Notwithstanding anything
to the contrary stated above, this mutual release shall not operate to release the
Parties from any claims for latent defects or for indemnity for personal injury or
property damages. Further, this release shall not operate to impair or release any
existing warranty or warranty defenses.
4. Attorney Lien. Counsel for P1 Group, by signing below, waives any attorney
lien or lien right.
5. Notice of Board Approval. By no later than September 28, 2016, Joplin
Schools, through counsel, shall notify P1 Group’s and UCC’s counsel by email
regarding whether or not the Joplin Schools Board of Education has approved this
Agreement. If this Agreement is not approved by the Joplin Schools Board of
Education, this Agreement shall be null and void.
6. Dismissal of Lawsuit. Within two (2) business days after receipt by P1 Group of
both the Joplin Schools Payment and UCC Payment, the Parties shall dismiss all
claims and causes of action in the Lawsuit with prejudice, with each Party to bear
their own court costs, expert witness fees, and attorney’s fees.
7. Compromise of Disputed Claims. The Parties acknowledge that this is a
compromise of disputed claims. This Agreement shall not be construed as an
admission of liability, as each party denies any and all liability to each other and
denies the nature and extent of any damage claimed by any other party.
8. Binding Effect. This Agreement is binding upon the Parties, their successors,
insurers and assigns, and the Joplin Schools Board of Education, and its members.
The individual signing the document on behalf of each party is an authorized
representative and has the capacity to bind that party.
9. Entire Agreement. This Agreement contains the entire agreement between the
Parties, and there are no other agreements, promises or representations, whether
oral, written, express or implied, not expressly set forth in this Agreement. The
Parties also agree that all the terms of this Agreement are contractual and not a
mere recital.
10. Construction. This Agreement has been arrived at after thorough bargaining and
negotiations between the Parties, and after each Party sought and obtained legal
advice of counsel. The language of this Agreement is a product of the mutual
effort of the Parties. This Agreement shall be construed fairly as to all Parties; it
shall not be construed for or against any party on the basis of the extent to which
that party participated in its drafting.
11. Confidentiality. The Parties will, to the extent it is lawful, keep these terms
confidential and no publicity will be given to the terms. The Parties recognize P1
Group has business reasons to disclose the outcome to its customers or
prospective customers, and such disclosure shall not be a violation. The Parties
further recognize and agree that under the Missouri Sunshine Law, § 610.021, RSMo., Joplin Schools may be required to make this Agreement public upon final
disposition of the Lawsuit, and that disclosure by Joplin Schools of this agreement
to others shall not be a violation.
12. Applicable Law. This Agreement shall be governed by Missouri law, without
regard to conflict of law principles that might otherwise apply.
13. Attorneys’ Fees and Costs. In the event of a breach of this Agreement, the
breaching party shall pay all attorney’s fees, costs and expenses associated with
enforcing this agreement and collecting payment of all sums due. Interest shall
accrue on any late payments at the rate of 1.5% per month.
14. Counterparts. This Agreement may be executed by the Parties in counterparts,
which taken together, are deemed one and the same instrument.
15. Facsimile or Email Signature. This Agreement may be executed by facsimile or
e-mail signatures which shall be deemed to have the same force and effect as an
original signature.
Previous Posts
Koch: $2.5 million P1 settlement will come out of reserves
Joplin R-8 School District reaches settlement with P1 Group
Wonderful. Just wonderful. And all this in the vain hope that CJ could say school will start on time again.
ReplyDelete"5. Notice of Board Approval. By no later than September 28, 2016, Joplin Schools, through counsel, shall notify P1 Group’s and UCC’s counsel by email regarding whether or not the Joplin Schools Board of Education has approved this Agreement. If this Agreement is not approved by the Joplin Schools Board of Education, this Agreement shall be null and void."
ReplyDeleteIs this date the date when the settlement was approved by the Board?
@6:22 If so, nice transparency!
ReplyDeleteSo it sounds like by sticking to the lawsuit the district saved it paying about half of what P1 claimed it was owed.
ReplyDeleteWhich in the short term is financially good for the district, especially if the "might as well" work reimbursements don't come through, but in the medium term, at least, it will make it harder for them to get good terms from contractors they hire.
Then again, I suppose they're already living with that, the suit has been going on long enough, but with it being settled with a big payment to P1 that makes it clear the district was stiffing the company. UCC is also not going to be happy about the increased insurance costs they'll be paying going forward after using up all their coverage.
Also makes it even more clear we're well rid of Huff and Johnson, and I assume anyone else who was responsible for this Charlie Foxtrot.
@9:43 The settlement had a confidentiality clause that prevented the school from publicizing the details without a freedom of information request. The case was dismissed Friday and the school sent the notice the same day. How is that not transparent? I am not supporting the way it was done but to say it is not transparent is laughable.
ReplyDeleteIt would all be less odious if the contractors had done a decent job. This is what happens with the lowest bidder system and a rush job. Screw ups all over those buildings.
ReplyDeleteSuch as???
DeleteTell me please. Why Joplin gets so deep in trouble and other districts coast along seldom paying attorney fees or 2.5 million ins elements? I would fire many more and cleanse this rats nest.
ReplyDeleteNo one has a magic wand. Malfeasance that occured in the past is still being litigated. Change takes time...
Delete