It appears likely that Missouri voters will soon decide whether teachers should be evaluated and paid based on scores their students make on standardized tests.
Retired billionaire Rex Sinquefield has poured more than $1.3 million into an effort to put the issue, coupled with the elimination of teacher tenure, on the ballot.
The push across the country to make teachers "accountable" has led to the creation of value-added formulas that supposedly show the contributions that teachers make to the test scores of their students. What most of them have shown is that the highest scores are posted by the teachers who manage to get the best students.
Furthermore, as you might expect, these formulas do not take into account any of the other factors that go into test scores- everything from a student's poverty level to abuse at home, emotional problems, or even being under the weather on the day of the big tests.
Even without the ballot initiative, Missouri has been moving in the direction of basing part of a teacher's evaluation on test scores and the reason is purely financial. The Obama Administration's Education Department has made it clear that if you do not make scores a part of the process, you are not going to be receiving any federal money, and that, of course, is the language that speaks with the most clarity to our state officials. The moves have also been necessary in order for states to receive relief from the horribly conceived No Child Left Behind.
So in order to rake in Race to the Top money and to satisfy billionaires who have made it clear that they are not friends of public education, we continue moving in the direction of a nightmarish scenario where even great teachers can end up losing pay or their jobs because of the luck of the draw on which students they receive. And with the stakes raised for teachers and administrators to improve test scores, we are already seeing increased instances of cheating.
What the "reformers" who are pushing for these so-called value-added metrics are conveniently ignoring is that studies are showing that the system simply does not work.
One such study, released Tuesday by the American Educational Research Association finds little correlation between these value-added measures between testing and effective teaching. The shocker is that the study is based on data from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, which has been pushing the new methods of teacher evaluation.
One of the researchers who released the study, Morgan S. Polikoff of the University of Southern California, says the results show that value-added metrics are nowhere near being ready to use in teacher evaluations. Yet we are moving full speed ahead.
As long as we continue to believe that all of education's ills come from having "poor' teachers and never address the many other factors that contribute to student failure we are doomed to shortsighted reforms that in the long run will damage public education far more than it will help it.
This blog features news and commentary from Randy Turner, a former teacher, newspaper reporter and editor. Send news items or comments to rturner229@hotmail.com
Showing posts with label schools. Show all posts
Showing posts with label schools. Show all posts
Tuesday, May 13, 2014
Monday, April 28, 2014
Missouri may become second state to dump Common Core
This week the Missouri Senate will begin debating a bill that would require a rewriting of state standards. If the bill passes and is signed by Gov. Jay Nixon, it will make Missouri the second state to drop Common Core Standards:
Now the Senate is scheduled to debate legislation this week that would charge a panel of educators and parents with writing new student performance goals to replace Common Core. The House passed a similar bill earlier this month.
Critics of Common Core said lawmakers should have been consulted on the decision when the State Board of Education adopted the standards. They want Missouri to write its own student benchmarks with involvement from lawmakers.
“There was no open and transparent process,” said Sen. John Lamping, R-Ladue. “I think once Missourians found out they had no say on the adoption of those standards, they now want their own.”
Wednesday, January 08, 2014
Video: Rex Sinquefield: Public schools condemning students to life of failure, lack of opportunity
In this video posted on YouTube earlier today, retired billionaire Rex Sinquefield talks about how he plans to make a difference with his money, including his goal of eliminating all personal income tax and tax on profits.
On education, Sinquefield says, "The public school system is condemning them to a life of failure and lack of opportunity."
At least, he didn't repeat his earlier quote about the KKK creating public education.
Sinquefield has already contributed $750,000 this year to one of his front organizations attempting to put a measure on the ballot eliminating teacher tenure and forcing school districts to evaluate teachers based on the scores students make on standardized tests.
On education, Sinquefield says, "The public school system is condemning them to a life of failure and lack of opportunity."
At least, he didn't repeat his earlier quote about the KKK creating public education.
Sinquefield has already contributed $750,000 this year to one of his front organizations attempting to put a measure on the ballot eliminating teacher tenure and forcing school districts to evaluate teachers based on the scores students make on standardized tests.
Wednesday, January 01, 2014
Ravitch: "Reformers" want to dismantle public education, teaching profession
In a blog post today, top education blogger Diane Ravitch, a former official in the Department of Education under President George H. W. Bush, offers her year-in-review, including some positive things that have happened in education in 2013.
However, she opens her post with this spot-on assessment of what has been occurring across the United States:
More and more parents and teachers are awakening to the realization that the word “reform” has been hijacked by people who want to dismantle public education and the teaching profession. Those who have boldly named themselves the “reformers” are all too often working on behalf of turning public dollars over to private interests and to strip teachers of any due process, any collective-bargaining rights, any salary increment linked to their experience or their education. These so-called “reformers” reify test scores, making them the be-all and end-all of education and are eager to fire teachers and principals whose students don’t get the test scores that the computer says they should, and equally eager to close public schools with low scores and replace them with privately managed schools that all too often escape the same scrutiny as the public schools they replaced. The “reformers” care not at all about class size, indeed, they say they would prefer larger classes with “better teachers,” even though teachers say they can be better teachers with smaller classes, especially given the diversity of students in most public schools today, some of whom have disabilities, some of whom are learning English.
Our educators and schools now live under a Sword of Damocles fashioned by No Child Left Behind and Race to the Top. Those who cannot produce higher scores are doomed. This is madness. This is a game rigged to harm public schools, which is a fundamental institution of our democracy.
Check out her post to find out the successes people are starting to have fighting against the "reformers."
However, she opens her post with this spot-on assessment of what has been occurring across the United States:
More and more parents and teachers are awakening to the realization that the word “reform” has been hijacked by people who want to dismantle public education and the teaching profession. Those who have boldly named themselves the “reformers” are all too often working on behalf of turning public dollars over to private interests and to strip teachers of any due process, any collective-bargaining rights, any salary increment linked to their experience or their education. These so-called “reformers” reify test scores, making them the be-all and end-all of education and are eager to fire teachers and principals whose students don’t get the test scores that the computer says they should, and equally eager to close public schools with low scores and replace them with privately managed schools that all too often escape the same scrutiny as the public schools they replaced. The “reformers” care not at all about class size, indeed, they say they would prefer larger classes with “better teachers,” even though teachers say they can be better teachers with smaller classes, especially given the diversity of students in most public schools today, some of whom have disabilities, some of whom are learning English.
Our educators and schools now live under a Sword of Damocles fashioned by No Child Left Behind and Race to the Top. Those who cannot produce higher scores are doomed. This is madness. This is a game rigged to harm public schools, which is a fundamental institution of our democracy.
Check out her post to find out the successes people are starting to have fighting against the "reformers."
Friday, December 27, 2013
Video- PBS News Hour: Will Common Core Standards Succeed in Centralizing Student Learning
The panelists in this PBS News Hour appear to all favor Common Core Standards, but they address many of the problems with Common Core, including the fact that while many countries have standards like this, those countries use them to major student learning, while the U. S. is talking about using them to judge teacher quality.
Tuesday, December 24, 2013
Bill would force students who do poorly on state tests to attend summer school
Rep. Steve Cookson, R-Poplar Bluff, has filed a bill that would make summer school mandatory for Missouri students who make low grades on standardized tests.
In the accompanying video clip, some oppose Cookson's bill, HB 1139, because of the financial burden it would place on school districts. A better reason to oppose the idea is because students should not have to attend summer school based on their scores on poorly written standardized tests.
Cookson would also require that all students who do not receive either advanced or proficient on the tests have to go to summer school.
Cookson's bill would also not allow schools to start until September and would require them to finish by the end of May.
In the accompanying video clip, some oppose Cookson's bill, HB 1139, because of the financial burden it would place on school districts. A better reason to oppose the idea is because students should not have to attend summer school based on their scores on poorly written standardized tests.
Cookson would also require that all students who do not receive either advanced or proficient on the tests have to go to summer school.
Cookson's bill would also not allow schools to start until September and would require them to finish by the end of May.
Sunday, December 22, 2013
Placing technology ahead of teachers will not work
Some of the critics of this blog (and hard as it is to believe, there are a few) have said that my criticism of the use of laptops and IPads in our schools shows that I and other teachers are afraid of technology in the classroom.
Nothing could be further from the truth.
As anyone who has ever been a student in my classroom (and as far as I have been able to determine, that does not include any of my critics) I was always able to stay ahead of the curve when it came to using technology in the classroom.
If I had been allowed to continue my teaching, I have no doubt that I would have adjusted to the addition of IPads for every middle school student in the Joplin R-8 School District.
Unfortunately, that is more than I can say for the people who are implementing this ill-advised strategy. If you have watched the pronouncements of soon-to-be former Assistant Superintendent Angie Besendorfer you have heard her talk numerous times about the students learning on their own with teachers serving as facilitators rather than doing any teaching.
That is a recipe for disaster.
Of course, we love it when students run with what we give them and seek knowledge on their own, but that is never going to be the way most education works even if we have world class facilitators. Pushing this idea that teachers are not important and are interchangeable is doing a disservice to students. How many of us can think back to our school days and remember teachers who provided us with knowledge and inspired us to learn more?
How many people who have succeeded would have done so if educators in the 1960s, 1970s, and 1980s had simply been facilitators and had not provided us with the knowledge we needed to succeed?
Learning, no matter what people like Angie Besendorfer say, is not something that magically occurs when you hand a student a laptop or an IPad. What is ironic is that today's teachers are being devalued by administrators who, for the most part, have spent little time in the classroom. Those of us who received our education in public schools a few decades ago were used to having administrators who served several years in the classroom before becoming principals and superintendents.
In today's education, many are fast-tracking themselves into administrative positions and are more interested in building resumes than they are in building an educational foundation that will last far beyond their years.
Unfortunately, we live in a society where the path to the top is not achieved by administrators who build a strong foundation and an educational community. Those who succeed and end up making salaries three or four times as much as the classroom teachers they often treat like disposable commodities are the ones who are willing to latch on to any new program, or several at once, just to be able to show they are innovative.
They move on, often leaving their former school systems in debt and having to recover from all of the "innovation."
Their school systems are loaded with technology and buzz-word programs, often at the expense of teachers and students.
Take a look at your local school district. Is that what is happening?
Nothing could be further from the truth.
As anyone who has ever been a student in my classroom (and as far as I have been able to determine, that does not include any of my critics) I was always able to stay ahead of the curve when it came to using technology in the classroom.
If I had been allowed to continue my teaching, I have no doubt that I would have adjusted to the addition of IPads for every middle school student in the Joplin R-8 School District.
Unfortunately, that is more than I can say for the people who are implementing this ill-advised strategy. If you have watched the pronouncements of soon-to-be former Assistant Superintendent Angie Besendorfer you have heard her talk numerous times about the students learning on their own with teachers serving as facilitators rather than doing any teaching.
That is a recipe for disaster.
Of course, we love it when students run with what we give them and seek knowledge on their own, but that is never going to be the way most education works even if we have world class facilitators. Pushing this idea that teachers are not important and are interchangeable is doing a disservice to students. How many of us can think back to our school days and remember teachers who provided us with knowledge and inspired us to learn more?
How many people who have succeeded would have done so if educators in the 1960s, 1970s, and 1980s had simply been facilitators and had not provided us with the knowledge we needed to succeed?
Learning, no matter what people like Angie Besendorfer say, is not something that magically occurs when you hand a student a laptop or an IPad. What is ironic is that today's teachers are being devalued by administrators who, for the most part, have spent little time in the classroom. Those of us who received our education in public schools a few decades ago were used to having administrators who served several years in the classroom before becoming principals and superintendents.
In today's education, many are fast-tracking themselves into administrative positions and are more interested in building resumes than they are in building an educational foundation that will last far beyond their years.
Unfortunately, we live in a society where the path to the top is not achieved by administrators who build a strong foundation and an educational community. Those who succeed and end up making salaries three or four times as much as the classroom teachers they often treat like disposable commodities are the ones who are willing to latch on to any new program, or several at once, just to be able to show they are innovative.
They move on, often leaving their former school systems in debt and having to recover from all of the "innovation."
Their school systems are loaded with technology and buzz-word programs, often at the expense of teachers and students.
Take a look at your local school district. Is that what is happening?
Thursday, December 19, 2013
Monday, December 09, 2013
State Board President- Don't just blame Nicastro; we're throwing KC Schools under the bus, too
State Board of Education Peter Hershend wasted no time responding to the bombshell article in Sunday's Kansas City Star detailing how Commissioner Chris Nicastro engineered the awarding of a contract to devise a plan for failing schools to the CEE-Trust, an organization that is almost completely funded by those who want to privatize education, including Kansas City's Kauffman Foundation and the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation.
Hershend wants everyone to know that the decision was the right one, the "clear choice" for Kansas City Public Schools and other "failing" school districts.
Hershend conveniently neglected to mention the vast strides the Kansas City Schools made during the past year, instead concentrating on every negative statistic he could drum up to show that the decision to leave KCPS unaccredited was the right one.
The text of the statement is printed below:
(From the Missouri State Board of Education)
We know that everyone has an interest in improving KCPS as well as Normandy and Riverview Gardens in St. Louis. We must lay aside political differences and allegiances and come together to make schools work better for our kids. They deserve nothing less than our best efforts, and they deserve them now.
Hershend wants everyone to know that the decision was the right one, the "clear choice" for Kansas City Public Schools and other "failing" school districts.
Hershend conveniently neglected to mention the vast strides the Kansas City Schools made during the past year, instead concentrating on every negative statistic he could drum up to show that the decision to leave KCPS unaccredited was the right one.
The text of the statement is printed below:
(From the Missouri State Board of Education)
State Board of Education President Peter Herschend issued the following statement in response to the Kansas City Star's article on the selection of CEE-Trust:
The Missouri State Board of Education made the ultimate decision in selecting CEE-Trust after an open and competitive bid process, and CEE-Trust was the clear choice for conducting analyses and making recommendations for transforming Kansas City Public Schools (KCPS).
It’s important to note that CEE-Trust’s recommendations will be one proposal among several other useful approaches – including a framework from the superintendent association – coming forward for the management of failing schools.
After the passage of Senate Bill 125, the Board – along with the rest of the state – urged the Department and the Commissioner to act swiftly to institute change in unaccredited school districts, but some groups are fighting even suggestions of change.
Change is always hard and many will oppose change, but what we are doing now is not working. We as a state and the State Board of Education have to find better ways of helping students, schools, teachers and education leadership over the barrier of failing schools.
After more than 30 years of failure in KCPS, we need to seize this moment to have a community conversation about how we educate our kids. We ask that you reserve judgment before any plan has been formulated or even ideas discussed. All of the recommendations for school system transformation will be debated by teachers, parents, students and community leaders. Ultimately, our hope is that the analyses and debate will result in a better future for our children.
We want to be clear about the current performance of schools in Kansas City. Here is a look at where KCPS currently stands:
- In mathematics and English language arts, only about 30 percent of all reportable KCPS students scored proficient in 2012-2013. In English language arts for grades 3-8, all grades are below 30 percent proficient.
- In English language arts, the MAP Performance Index (MPI) averaged across all grade levels actually declined over the past three years. Last year's third grade proficiency rate of 23.12 percent was lower than it was in 2007.
- Proficiency improved in science and social studies, but student scores remained below 30 percent proficient across all students in both subjects.
- KCPS's higher performance is concentrated in selective enrollment signature schools. In high school math, for example, most schools that exceeded state averages in Algebra I, were signature schools. For the three schools that accept all students, Algebra I proficiency rates were 32.8 percent, 16.1 percent and 12.1 percent.
- Similarly, while the graduation rate at East High School improved in 2012-13, graduation rates averaged across all open enrollment high schools was below 60 percent. That means that more than four out of 10 students in Kansas City's non-selective high schools failed to complete high school.
- Average student growth in KCPS is below the state average in both English and math, which are the only two subjects for which the state measures growth. Some may argue that Kansas City’s proficiency rates are low because of a low starting point, so there’s more room for progress to allow the district to catch up. Yet the district earned the state's lowest rating for growth in both ELA and math in 2012-13. This means the KCPS students grew less on average than their peers across Missouri, falling further behind rather than catching up.
We know that everyone has an interest in improving KCPS as well as Normandy and Riverview Gardens in St. Louis. We must lay aside political differences and allegiances and come together to make schools work better for our kids. They deserve nothing less than our best efforts, and they deserve them now.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


