Thursday, March 09, 2006

Joplin R-8 accomplishment fails to make Globe

The Missouri Department of Elementary and Secondary Education revealed Wednesday that the Joplin R-8 School District had outperformed every school district in southwest Missouri and had been near the top in the state as far as improvement in MAP scores was concerned. And as all of us in education know, MAP scores are the benchmark by which all Missouri schools are judged.

The Joplin Daily began its story this way:

"Schools in the Joplin R-8 School District made state lists for top 10 most improved schools while the district itself was listed as the third most-improved district in Missouri, according to a written release from the school district.

" 'To be ranked third in the state is a tremendous accomplishment," said Superintendent Jim Simpson. Our students, teachers, and principals have worked very hard to make students performance a priority and this recognition reflects their efforts and their commitment.' "

This is how The Joplin Globe began its article in today's edition:






Perhaps the news is prominently featured in the print edition. All I have seen is what Globe editors have posted on the website, but I can find no mention of this accomplishment.
Two years ago when state officials designated the R-8 School District as one of the few in the state that was "accredited with distinction" the Globe pretty much passed it off as if it were an everyday accomplishment. The article ran on page one, but Joplin was lumped in with Webb City and Carl Junction, two other area schools which also recorded the accomplishment. The rarity of the achievement was not addressed. The fact that three schools in such a close proximity made it might appear like it was not worth much. As I recall, those three school districts were the only ones in this region to be honored. It should be mentioned, the key factor in receiving "Accredited with Distinction" is how students fare on MAP tests.
This last fall, the Joplin R-8 School District was the only district in the state to be "Accredited with Distinction." The accomplishment was barely mentioned in the Globe and was not treated as a major page one story. I can't recall what the lead story was that day, but I am sure it was some regional controversy.
Some of you may recall the story a few years back of the Joplin R-8 teacher who was arrested on drug charges. Now that was a page one story. A sleazy article last year about a Joplin R-8 Board member, totally based on hearsay, also received the page one buildup.
The Joplin R-8 School District reaching the top in the state, however, does not even merit a mention on the Globe website. Hopefully, this is an oversight and the story is in the print edition or Globe editors and reporters are working overtime on a comprehensive package detailing the district's accomplishments. Until then, I will be content to read what John Hacker and Kaylea Hutson have to say about the district in the Joplin Daily.
***
For those who have not seen the Daily article, six Joplin R-8 schools, including South Middle School, where I teach, Memorial Middle School, and four elementary schools, Duenweg, Royal Heights, Columbia, and Cecil Floyd (Duenweg placed in both math and communication arts, while the other elementary schools scored in math. Both South and Memorial middle schools scored high in communication arts.)
The only other area school districts to place were: McDonald County (5) and Nevada (1). The only school districts to place more schools on the list than Joplin were: St. Louis City 16 and Springfield 9.
***
Note: Before the negative element of the Turner Report readership begins posting responses, it should be noted that the communication arts scores at South Middle School, which were up 21 percent last year, had nothing whatsoever to do with my teaching. Seventh graders took the test, not eighth graders. The teachers responsible were seventh grade communications arts teacher Angel Mense, reading teacher Linda Weaver, and the sixth grade teachers and elementary teachers who provided the students with the foundation for their accomplishments. You can also add to that list, sixth and seventh grade teachers in other subjects who have increased the amount of writing required in their courses, adminisrators who have set the goals and provided the support to reach them, and of course, the students who supplied the performances that put South at the top.
***
The local television stations all offered excellent reports on their 10 p.m. newscasts, leaving the Globe the only one out of the loop, since I just checked its print edition and cannot find a mention of the R-8 accomplishment.

14 comments:

Anonymous said...

And how many times did you apply to work at The Globe?

Yeah, the paper dropped the ball. They don't have a clue. We know that if they'd hired you the circulation would be up, the wall would be lined with Pulitzers, and everyday would be 70 degrees and sunny.

You don't have a clue. Your years of journalism experience were at minor papers in minor communities. Your posts are soaked with jealousy and libel.

Randy said...

This is the same approach that politicians often take when someone writes something about them. They attack the person who delivers the message, completely avoiding the truth that was in the message. My dealings with the Globe have been completely spelled out in earlier posts, as you are well aware and some of the finest journalism in the United States takes place at weeklies and small daily newspapers. I also do not appreciate your attack on Carthage, Lamar, Lockwood or Granby as "minor communities."
However, that is one of the attractions of blogs. Any jackass can bray under the protective cloak of anonymity.

Anonymous said...

Mr Negative Element I really really do not like you saying the Randy only worked in minor communities, Carthage is NOT minor to anyone or anyplace, neither is Lamar but I don't live there. Joplin may be bigger but that does not make it better. When we moved back here from the east we knew it would have to be near Joplin for my husbands work but there was no way we wanted to live in the land of the metal sided buildings. We wanted culture and history and of course a good political arena and Joplin has none of that.

Anonymous said...

If Carthage and Lamar are minor, why does The Globe bother covering them extensively? Randy is a fine reporter and editor, a little self-important, but otherwise one of the good guys.

Anonymous said...

To say the Globe covers Lamar extensively is a little of an overstatement, isn't it.

Anonymous said...

Since when does the Lamar Democrat rank up there with the NY Times? Listening to Randy I would think that it has the circulation of USA Today. Randy is an elitest without the portfolio.

Did you ask the Globe why it didn't cover the story? They made a mistake, but you just gloat. You don't care about getting to the bottom of the story. You just want to poor salt in the wounds and kick the dead horse. That's why you never became Bob Woodward.

Anonymous said...

No it's not an overstatement. For being 45 minutes away, events that occur there often find their way to the front page of THE JOPLIN-FREAKING GLOBE.

Anonymous said...

The Globe sucks. No one can deny that. What's more pathetic is that Randy gets special pleasure out of nitpicking the rag.

Anonymous said...

That's the point of this blog, you dolt; to nitpick the minutae. Go read Highlights if you don't want to read criticism.

Anonymous said...

Keep up the good work, Randy. I guess you have to expect personal attacks from anonymous backshooters, but most of us who read your writing but rarely post comments do so because we value the information you provide; information that the globe doesn't print. We many appreciate your efforts and we ignore the petty snipes of the few jealous idiots who mistake a smartass remark for wit or insight.

Anonymous said...

Just a question - after all the sniping about Randy, did anyone actually read what was in the post? How about we comment on how the Joplin Schools did in academic improvement? Such a great thing for this community and what becomes the focus of the comments?

Does not make sense to me.

Anonymous said...

Wow, Randy, you've really brainwashed your students and backward Diamond types. Keep up the good work. Why don't you quit your job and go back into journalism? You're going to save the profession all by yourself.

Michelle said...

Coward is right. I know I say this almost every time I comment here, but I love how every has the guts to say comments, so long as there's no way that they're held accountable for them. At any rate, anyone who accuses Mr. Turner of doing the brainwashing in Diamond obviously hasn't visited here in a while. And buddy, I'm sure there's just as many "backwards people" wherever you're from, because this entire area is pretty saturated with them.

Anonymous said...

i am not wearing red pants but i do wear yellow and green ones only with polka dots or vertical stripes>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> here read these words.....................