Wednesday, January 04, 2023

New Missouri House speaker says huge budget surplus should mean more tax cuts


By Jason Hancock and Rudi Keller

Missouri’s top lawmaker opened the 2023 legislative session Wednesday by proclaiming that the state’s massive budget surplus should translate into more tax cuts.

House Speaker Dean Plocher, R-Des Peres, noted that Missouri lawmakers approved a nearly $800 million tax cut in September. But with a projected state budget surplus of $6 billion, Plocher believes “there is more room to return money to Missouri taxpayers.”

(Photo- Missouri House Speaker Dean Plocher, R-Des Peres-Tim Bommel/Missouri House Communications).

While his speech Wednesday to the Missouri House didn’t delve into details of any tax cut plan, its inclusion in his opening day address signals the issue’s importance to the new speaker. And speaking to reporters later in the day, Plocher said he’s open to multiple ideas to reduce the tax burden on Missourians, from income tax cuts to trimming the stales tax to changes in personal property tax.






 

“Reducing our tax burden will make Missouri even more competitive to recruit a talented workforce, to build prosperous communities, grow small businesses and create more opportunities for all,” he said.

In addition to tax cuts, Plocher also vowed to take steps to increase teacher pay.

Since 2010, the minimum starting pay for a teacher in Missouri has been $25,000. Lawmakers added $21.8 million to this year’s budget to fund a grant program to raise base pay to $38,000. About 12% of the state’s 70,400 teachers make less than that amount, the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education estimates.

School districts had to provide 30% of the cost to be eligible. If the state mandates a minimum pay, it must fund it. Paterson said he’s ready for that commitment.

In October, the Teacher Recruitment and Retention Blue Ribbon Commission made raising the minimum salary to $38,000 its top recommendation among nine proposals to alleviate the teacher shortage being felt by rural and urban districts alike.

Shortages are particularly acute for elementary, early childhood and special education, as well as in specific subjects and high-need schools.

“For too long our teachers have been compensated by an out-of-date pay scale. It’s a flawed system that rewards time served instead of output and innovation,” Plocher said Wednesday. “Teaching is difficult and our state needs to reward teachers for success so our children have access, both to great teachers and choices for education.”

Beyond increasing teacher pay, Plocher hinted at a legislative push to regulate school curriculum, saying parents should have a stronger voice as it relates to the substance of what is taught to their kids each day.”

Among the bills filed pertaining to school curriculum include bans on what is known as “critical race theory” and a “Parents Bill of Rights” that would allow parents to object to and opt out of “any instructional materials” they find objectionable.

In a portion of the speech addressing violent crime, Plocher took a shot at local leaders in Kansas City and St. Louis — though not by name — in saying that many have “lost trust in dysfunctional local governments where some officials refuse to prosecute violent offenders.”








“We cannot be bystanders as unchecked crime causes the systematic destruction of our proud state,” Plocher said. “There is no excuse for inaction.”

House Minority Leader Crystal Quade, D-Springfield, spoke on the session’s opening day against a GOP-backed plan to change the initiative petition process to make it harder to amend the constitution.

“Any attempt to strip people of their power to propose and enact laws is antithetical to democracy,” Quade said.

She also noted that while major disagreements exist between her party and the Republicans —notably over abortion rights and gun safety — there are also major areas where they are on the same page, echoing Plocher’s call that a priority of the 2023 session should be raising teacher pay and improving access to childcare.

“We can agree that boosting teacher pay has to happen,” she said, “and that finding quality and affordable childcare has to be a priority to address our workforce issues and to ensure that our kids start off with the support that they need.”

Both the House and the state Senate kicked off the 2023 legislative session at noon. The session ends at 6 p.m. on May 12.

Missouri Senate

In a 10-minute speech in the Senate, new President Pro Tem Caleb Rowden, R-Columbia, asked members to consider their place in history and to reject the factional splits that undermined the chamber’s work in 2022.

“We must care more about the policy than we do the personality,” Rowden said. “We must work toward retiring revenge, and not recycling it. And we must break the cycle of governing by fear and half truths.”








The policies he wants the Senate to address, Rowden said, would provide more health care coverage to new mothers, continue benefit programs as family income increases to provide a smooth transition off public assistance, make it harder to amend the constitution and overhaul education.

In an interview last month with The Independent, Rowden said the ideas he would include in his opening-day address reflect “broad consensus” in the Republican caucus.

He asked senators to pass Sen. Elaine Gannon’s bill extending Medicaid services to mothers for a year after delivery. The coverage currently ends 60 days after a woman gives birth. The bill fell victim to factional fighting last year.

And Rowden said he wants to pass Sen. Mary Elizabeth Coleman’s bill to continue benefits when a family’s income rises.

“Being pro-life means standing for Missouri’s vulnerable populations,” Rowden said.

Rowden made changing education a two-year project for the Senate. Public schools are struggling with a teacher shortage, and a state commission recommended nine steps, including much higher minimum salaries. Other lawmakers are worried more districts will move to a four-day week, which will aggravate the issues surrounding child care availability.

The education changes must “redefine” student and school success, Rowden said.

“In Missouri, world-class schools should be treated and funded like world-class schools,” he said. “World-class teachers should be paid like world-class teachers.”

Senate Minority Leader John Rizzo, D-Independence, said in a press release that Missourians want “commonsense solutions to the problems facing our state. People are tired of the extremist rhetoric and chaotic partisanship that puts special interests ahead of working families.”

Democrats in the Senate will prioritize teacher pay increases, solutions to a childcare shortage and expanding access to reproductive healthcare.

The party is also focused on gun safety, Rizzo said.

“Missouri is in the middle of a gun violence epidemic,” he said, “we can fix that by giving police the tools they need to stop killers when there are clear red flags. Missouri has real problems, and Democrats are here to offer real solutions.”

Jill Carter sworn in 32nd District state senator


(From Sen. Jill Carter, R-Granby)

State Sen. Jill Carter, R-Granby, took the oath of office and was sworn in as a member of the 102nd General Assembly on Jan. 4, 2023. She represents the 32nd Senatorial District consisting of Jasper and Newton counties. The swearing in ceremony marks the beginning of the 2023 legislative session which runs from Jan. 4 to May 12.

A wife, mother and grandmother with a passion for education, Sen. Carter is a graduate of Crowder College and a resident of Granby for 36 years. 








Senator Carter comes from a long line of family farmers, owned a small, local business for 15 years and values the principles of hard work and integrity.

“It is an honor to represent the people of the 32nd Senatorial District,” Sen. Carter said. “I am grateful for their support and will do my very best to protect the Southwest Missouri values and principles that make Missouri the best state in the Union.”

Missouri lawmakers reconvene focusing on sports betting, teacher pay, initiative petition


By Rudi Keller

Before the Kansas City Chiefs defeated the Los Angeles Rams on Nov. 27, GeoComply defeated 82,000 attempts by Missourians to access sports gambling sites.

Missouri hasn’t legalized sports wagering, and a gambler must be in a state that has, like Kansas or Illinois, to make a legal bet.

The blocked bets before the Chiefs’ game are among 5.7 million blocked attempts by Missourians to log on to gambling sites between Sept. 1 and Dec. 16, according to data GeoComply provided to The Independent.

(Photo- The Missouri House chamber during the 2022 legislative session- Tim Bommel/Missouri House Communications).








Some people won’t take no for an answer. The information from GeoComply notes that devices linked to 1,270 users were located on both sides of the Kansas border between Nov. 16 and Dec. 16.

“Same username, same device, realistic velocity crossing the (Kansas) border,” the company states.

Among them was Missouri Senate Minority Leader John Rizzo.

“I have absolutely gone to Kansas and made a bet before,” Rizzo, D-Independence, said in an interview with The Independent. “I would say the overwhelming majority of sports enthusiasts in the Kansas City area have made a bet in Kansas.”

The effort to legalize sports betting in the state begins anew at noon, when lawmakers begin their annual session. For a vocal slice of Missouri’s population, sports wagering is the most important item on the agenda.

There will be eight new senators in the 34-member upper chamber and 38 new representatives in the 163-member House. And there’s plenty more for lawmakers to work on once the chambers get organized.








The Independent spoke with the top legislative leaders of both parties and found bipartisan agreement that something must be done to increase teacher pay and improve access to child care.

Missouri has a massive budget surplus, more than $6 billion. Gov. Mike Parson will reveal his budget priorities on Jan. 18.

But the legislative session won’t be entirely bipartisan hosannas. GOP leaders said hot-button cultural issues — such as limiting transgender students’ participation in school sports and banning “critical race theory” in classrooms — will get lots of early attention.

“I’d like to get at least two of them done before spring break,” said Senate Majority Leader Cindy O’Laughlin, R-Shelbina, referring to bills pertaining to school curriculum and transgender athletes.

A series of conservative losses at the polls on policy issues such as Medicaid expansion and minimum wage, as well as likely petitions protecting abortion rights, is adding to the Republican effort to the threshold for constitutional amendments proposed by initiative.

Democrats are ready to resist any GOP push on controversial cultural issues, Rizzo said. Instead, he said lawmakers should focus on bipartisan issues like school funding.

“Instead,” Rizzo said, “the one thing they want to bring it back to, consistently, are these culture war issues.”

Gambling expansion

The issue of gambling is a triangular debate.

Casino companies and professional sports teams are eager for the revenue from sports wagering and will be back with a proposal that slices up the market to their liking. Video game vendors want lawmakers to authorize a new form of lottery game for people to play in bars, truck stops and fraternal halls.

And companies facing criminal prosecution for placing games that pay prize money in convenience stores and other locations through the state don’t want any bill that would make the law clear on their legality.

Sports betting, said the top legislative leaders of both parties, is what they hear about constantly from family, friends and constituents.

“It is a topic of conversation everywhere I have been,” said House Minority Leader Crystal Quade, D-Springfield.

“All the time,” said Senate President Pro Tem Caleb Rowden, R-Columbia, when asked how often someone brings up the subject of sports wagering.








House Majority Leader Jonathan Patterson, R-Lee’s Summit, said the chat is amplified by television ads and billboards plastering the Kansas City area promoting sports wagering in Kansas.

“It is something that a lot of people want to have,” Patterson said. “It seems a little silly for people in Kansas City to have to go over to the other side and place their bets there.”

The high public interest will push lawmakers to early action, Patterson said.

“I would rank it pretty high because of the fact that our citizens obviously want it,” he said. “There also is a revenue component to it. That money can be used for education. I think the importance is high and it does provide meaningful revenue.”

Teacher pay

Since 2010, the minimum starting pay for a teacher in Missouri has been $25,000. On Sunday, the state’s minimum wage increased to $12 an hour, equal to $24,960.

A teacher who sticks with the job for 10 years and gets a master’s degree must be paid at least $33,000. A person capable of working in a warehouse with no specific education requirement can earn $44,000.

In October, the Teacher Recruitment and Retention Blue Ribbon Commission made raising the minimum salary to $38,000 its top recommendation among nine proposals to alleviate the teacher shortage being felt by rural and urban districts alike.

Shortages are particularly acute for elementary, early childhood and special education, as well as in specific subjects and high-need schools.

Lawmakers added $21.8 million to this year’s budget to fund a grant program to raise base pay to $38,000. About 12% of the state’s 70,400 teachers make less than that amount, the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education estimates.

School districts had to provide 30% of the cost to be eligible. If the state mandates a minimum pay, it must fund it. Paterson said he’s ready for that commitment.

“Missouri is very low in terms of what it offers to first-year teachers and veteran teachers,” he said. “We would like to see what we can do to raise teacher pay on top of the one-time program.”

While policymakers at the state level debate pay rates and other incentives to teach, districts are increasingly turning a funding expedient into a recruiting tool. By going to a four-day week, the 14,000 student Independence School District is offering extra free time as a benefit.

“The main thing, looking at this, is we wanted to see if it would help retain and recruit staff,” Independence Superintendent Dale Herl said last month.

Roughly 12% of the state’s public school K-8 students now attend class four days per week, mainly in rural districts. The move by Independence schools is a symptom of one problem and an extra burden for another, Rizzo said.

It is a symptom that the state isn’t meeting its education funding obligation under budgets and policies set by the GOP majority over the past two decades, he said.

“The Republican Party has been working for decades to destroy the public school system,” he said.

It will aggravate the already difficult problem of child care outside of school, which is keeping a lot of people, mainly women, out of the workforce, Rizzo said.

“It cost us $1.4 billion in lost revenue for a lack of child care,” he said.

Child care

Full-time child care for an infant in urban areas of Missouri can cost $180 to $250 a week, or almost 20% of average household income.

A couple with one child can receive a full state subsidy with an annual income up to $34,500 and a partial subsidy with an income up to $55,700.

The difficulty is finding affordable care, either where it is scarce, as in rural areas, or where demand outstrips supply in urban and suburban areas. Since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, Missourinet recently reported, 400 child care providers have closed with no plans to reopen.

A report by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce published in 2021 found the disruptions tied to child-care cost the state economy $1.35 billion annually in lost productivity and tax revenue.

The industry has received massive infusions of federal funds to stay open and expand amid the COVID-19 crisis, including $444.1 million in the current fiscal to pay retention bonuses, start-up and expansion costs, and maintain payrolls.

The economy can employ everyone willing to work, Patterson said, and the state needs to promote participation.

“Right now we have historically low unemployment, so the problem is not, are there jobs, but what we hear from employers over and over is finding people to fill those jobs,” he said. “It goes hand in hand with workforce development and the economy as a whole.”

Quade, who said Democrats have “ a really great relationship” with the new Republican leaders, said the effort to solve the child care problem will be bipartisan.

“Child care is at the top of the list for us,” Quade said, “and I am hoping it is going to be for the governor as well.”

Budget surplus

Before lawmakers convened last year, Parson announced he would ask them to raise the pay for all state employees by 5.5% and set a $15 an hour base wage for state jobs. The proposal was intended to cut down on turnover in state jobs.








Parson hasn’t made any of his spending plans known ahead of this year’s session but the massive budget surplus – more $6 billion as of November – is attracting plenty of attention.

Sen. Bill Eigel, who is considering a bid for governor, was out early with his plan to set aside billions to widen Interstate 70 to four lanes in each direction across the state. Rowden, however, in a recent interview with Missourinet, said Eigel’s idea isn’t feasible.

One of the most pressing needs for state money, Democratic leaders said, is public schools. The foundation formula, the process for distributing $3.5 billion in school aid, is tied to a figure called the state adequacy target, which is intended to be a calculation of the minimum amount needed to provide an adequate education.

When instituted in 2006, the adequacy target was supposed to be recalculated every two years. The initial calculation that year was $6,117 per student, which is $9,111 in inflation-adjusted dollars. The current figure, unchanged for four years, is $6,325.

“It is time to invest in Missourians and figure out how to do that in a way that both sides of the aisle can support,” Quade said when asked about Democratic budget priorities.

“What I don’t want to see is all this money go to people’s pet projects,” she added.

Rizzo, who lives in Independence, said he has been trying for years to get Republicans to spend more on education.

“I don’t know how many times I have to yell at people, one of our biggest school districts just went to 4-day weeks,” Rizzo said.

Lawmakers must balance spending choices with saving money to cover potential revenue shortfalls, Patterson said.

The consensus revenue estimate is a dark cloud inside the silver lining of the surplus. Revenues have grown at double-digit rates for more than two years but that is expected to slow dramatically in the spring.

“We do want to spend that money wisely, because revenues will not always be so robust,” Patterson said.

Infrastructure spending will provide a long-term return and a wider I-70 would be welcome, Patterson said.

“As a person that travels on I-70, I am definitely open to any ideas we have about improving it,” he said. “I would still have to be convinced that using general revenue for I-70 would be the best idea.”

Extending Medicaid coverage for pregnant women to one-year after delivery will need both authorizing legislation and a budget appropriation. The proposal, which had bipartisan support as a measure to address maternal mortality, was blocked by Senate conservatives last year.

Patterson said it will “get a lot of attention” in the House this year.

Culture issues

Republican leaders told The Independent they want peace on culture war issues and are willing to make accommodations with Democrats to achieve it.

“One way to keep from running into all kinds of issues is to bring everybody into the conversation,” O’Laughlin said. “Not just people in your caucus, but people in the other caucus and try to work with people.”

The problem, leaders of both parties said, will be convincing rank-and-file members to accept anything that is less than ideologically pure.

“I would hope discussion would bring thoughtful discourse about how we are educating our children,” Quade said. “But that’s not what it has been. It is usually one side yelling at the other side.”

Republicans have filed 10 bills to limit the ability of transgender minors to play in youth sports. There are bills on how medical providers treat children with gender dysphoria as well as proposed bans on the discussion of sexual and gender identity by school personnel.

The bills do nothing to address real problems in education and punish families already dealing with stressful issues, Quade said.

“I am tired of having these little kids and their families having to come and justify their existence in our Capitol,” she said.

Patterson said he wants the legislation to focus on fairness.

“There’s a way to address it to where we are able to accept and honor those students who are transgender,” he said. “These are not bills that are going after them. We want them to have a place in the school system. There is also an issue of fairness and safety involved in high-level scholastic sports.”

Conservative lawmakers have also pushed a bill they call a “Parents’ Bill of Rights” that would allow lawsuits against school districts and cuts in state funding for violations. Some of the more controversial provisions would allow parents to object to and opt out of “any instructional materials” they find objectionable, and for districts to publicly post curriculum and materials taught and speakers and guests used for professional development.

Opponents call the bill an attempt to disrupt and undermine public education.

Other Republican legislation seeks to limit how history is taught to ban what is known as “critical race theory.”

Patterson, a physician and the first Asian-American to lead House Republicans, said his understanding of critical race theory is that it is a “graduate-level academic framework. By definition, that is something that should not be required.”

History, he said, should be taught factually.

“Students should be taught history and learn about the great things that have been done and the things that were not always reflective of our highest ideals,” he said.

If Republicans want discussions that are serious, Rizzo said, he’s ready to have them. But culture issues, however framed, are a waste of time.

And, he said, it isn’t working politically.

“It is almost like they didn’t get the memo,” he said, “that the 2016 anger and fear and hatred doesn’t work.”

Tuesday, January 03, 2023

Arkansas Republican: With Billy Long gone, Republicans searching for new class clown

 Apparently, some people recognized former Seventh District Congressman Billy Long's value to the Republican Party and to Congress.

In an article posted on Politico concerning incoming Rep. Tim Burchett, R-Tennessee becoming the new source of humor for the Republicans, Rep. Steve Womack, R-Arkansas, praised his predecessor in that category, Billy Long.

“With Billy Long leaving Congress, the conference is in search of a new class clown,” said Rep. Steve Womack (R-Ark.). “And I nominate Tim Burchett … he’s so unpredictable. He says the craziest things.”


Delays to shut down Agape dishearten former students


By Clara Bates

When he read the news back in September that Missouri had moved to shut down Agape Boarding School, Allen Knoll felt a sense of vindication.

”For me personally,” he said, “but also for current victims.”

It was over a year and a half after Knoll had traveled to Missouri from Washington state to testify in front of the legislature about his time as a student at the Stockton-based Christian boarding school, detailing the abuse he says he suffered at the school and urging lawmakers to pass legislation to regulate faith-based unlicensed boarding schools.

(Photo- Allen Knoll, who was sent to Agape Boarding School in Missouri, testified during a committee hearing on Feb. 10, 2021, about abuse he says he endured there.- Photo by Tim Bommel/House Communications)

It was also over a year after the legislation he pushed for had gone into effect.






 

The state filed for an injunction to close the school — a measure activists like Knoll, who co-founded a nonprofit advocating for reform to the so-called troubled teen industry, had been publicly demanding for months. And a judge seemed ready to close the school for good.

“I felt like, cool, those kids are going to be somewhere safe,” Knoll said of the students then at the school.

But his vindication quickly turned to resignation.

The judge initially signaled the school could shut down immediately, then delayed any decision over a weekend. More delays followed, and three months later, the school remains open, pending a still-unscheduled trial set to take place sometime next year.

“I was happy and then heartbroken,” Knoll said in an interview last week. “I feel like I didn’t do my job good enough, maybe there’s something I can do.”

The delays are just the latest frustration for former students who have publicly accused the school of physical, mental and sexual abuse.

Criminal charges against school leaders fell short of what the state attorney general recommended, and a push by the state to put the school’s director on a child abuse registry — and thus ban him from working at the school — was upended, for the time being, by a Cole County judge last week.

The school, which has been subject to intense social media pressure from activists and at least 20 lawsuits, remains open and has vehemently denied allegations of wrongdoing.

Meanwhile, efforts to shut Agape down continue to drag on as Attorney General Eric Schmitt, whose office is leading the charge to shutter the school, is set to step down in January to join the U.S. Senate.

“Everyone’s flabbergasted by it,” James Griffey, who attended Agape as a student from 1998 to 2001 and left in 2002 after working on staff, said of the developments that have allowed the school to stay open.

“What kind of evidence do they need?”

Immediate health and safety concern

In more than 20 lawsuits against the school, former students detail a range of allegation, from having food withheld as punishment to being forced to submit to physical labor and extreme exercise to being taken off prescribed medications.

An investigation by The Kansas City Star beginning in 2020 included interviews from dozens of former students spanning decades who made similar abuse allegations. Agape denies any wrongdoing.

Missouri’s attorney general, along with the state Department of Social Services, filed for an injunction on Sept. 7 seeking to close Agape, alleging an “immediate health and safety concern” to the children there.






 

The state’s push to close Agape relies on a law passed in 2021, which granted the attorney general’s office and Department of Social Services, as well as county prosecuting or circuit attorneys, the authority to seek injunctive relief to cease the operation of a residential care facility, and provide for appropriate removal of children in certain instances. The law also required residential facilities to conduct background checks on staff, which the state alleges Agape has violated.

After being tied up in court over several procedural matters, Agape Boarding School remains open despite the state’s findings that staff perpetrated child abuse and neglect.

There is no definite end in sight in the case.

Agape’s attorney told The Independent he expects the trial to occur early next year.

The social services department was allowed 24/7 emergency access to Agape beginning in September, when the case was originally delayed for a weekend, in order to monitor children’s safety. Over three months later, the social services department is still operating under court-approved access to the facility to monitor it.

“Agape remains open and the boys residing there are being safely cared for and educated,” John Schultz, Agape’s attorney in this case, said in an interview.

There are around 25 students there now, down from 121 early last year.

The state has argued that if not for the presence of social service workers there would be “real, immediate concerns that children at Agapé may be subject to current and future incidents of child abuse or neglect, and their health and safety cannot be assured.”

The judge in the case, Thomas Pyle in Cedar County, is set to retire December 31 and a new judge will be assigned, the Cedar County circuit clerk confirmed Tuesday by email.

Chris Nuelle, spokesperson for the attorney general’s office said, by email to The Independent last week: “We have fought hard to protect the students at Agape and litigate this case as aggressively as possible, and the office will continue to do so.”

One hurdle to trial cleared

A series of procedural delays hampered the state’s effort to close Agape. But the most significant hold up since September came awaiting a decision from the court of appeals that arrived earlier this month and possibly cleared the path forward for trial to occur more quickly in the new year.

Agape’s attorneys in early October sought to require the state to appoint court-appointed representatives, called guardian ad litems, for each child currently at Agape and to add all of their parents as parties in the case.

Pyle granted the request, which in turn inspired a push by Agape to move any potential trial date back.

Schultz said he asked for an extended trial date because appointing “28 guardian ad litems and bringing in 56 parents getting all their schedules, it’d be kind of difficult.”

The state argued that the case’s focus was to “cease business operations and return the children to their parents or legal guardians,” not a child custody case where a guardian ad litem would be required.

The Missouri Southern District Court of Appeals sided with the state, successfully vacating the judge’s order. But that took two months to decide.

Without the need for parents to become involved or guardian ad litems to appoint, Schultz said, “we can do it in pretty quick order, so whenever the judge can schedule, we’ll be ready.”

Emotional roller coaster

Griffey pointed to a Cole County judge’s decision last week not to place Agape’s longtime director, Bryan Clemensen, on the state child abuse registry as just the latest twist in an “emotional roller coaster.”

The state said it substantiated five preponderance of evidence findings against Clemensen — one count of child neglect and four of physical abuse. The judge said Clemensen should remain off the registry until a final judgment is issued in a full trial, or until further order from the court.

“I don’t know what they would think is abuse,” said Griffey, who alleges among the abuse he suffered was being punched in the face by a staff member the first night he was at Agape for saying the word “gosh.”

Last year, Cedar County prosecuting attorney Ty Gaither filed only a fraction of the criminal counts against Agape that Schmitt recommended after his office conducted an investigation.

The state blamed the local prosecutor’s office, saying they’d been “stymied” by “an uncooperative prosecutor at nearly every turn.” The Star has investigated ties between Agape and Cedar County law enforcement, including sheriff’s deputies who worked at Agape.

Gaither said recently that he filed so few counts because he does not believe the restraint and pain compliance techniques Agape staff allegedly performed qualify as abuse under Missouri law.

“We’ve laid down all the evidence, countless stories, countless testimonies,” said Colton Schrag, an Agape student from 2003 to 2004 and 2006 to 2010. “Staff members were found to have substantiated claims of abuse against them, and they’re still managing to operate.”

At Agape, where Knoll began as a student at age 13, in 1999 and left in 2001, he alleges he was routinely subject to physical abuse, including being pinned down by several staff members daily for hours at a time as a form of “compliance through pain.”

He alleges three or four staff members would hold down his arms, legs, and put a knee on his back, sometimes twisting his arms and pushing on the pressure point behind his neck he said, daily for over two months as a form of punishment when he refused to comply with directions, such as refusing to go to church.






 

Knoll said the activism of former students online has created its own kind of victory, although the “elation” among survivors they felt when they got the new regulations on boarding schools passed in 2021 has given way to frustration and a sense of “deflation.”

As Clemensen explained in testimony earlier this month, Agape is struggling financially, forced to transition to a group-home setup amid dwindling numbers of students.

“It’s a victory that’s to no credit to the politicians, it’s a victory to the survivors that have gone out there and gotten their stories told,” Knoll said. “These politicians aren’t responsible for the 90% decrease in enrollment. It was the survivors that went out there and were bold enough to tell their stories.”

Nonetheless, Knoll said, he still wants the state to remove the remaining children.

“They got the kids that are still there. They were like me, I was the throwaway child. Who’s gonna leave their kid at Agape after all these allegations?” Knoll said. “These are people that have abandoned their children. I was one of those kids.”

Missouri GOP renews push to limit transgender participation in school sports


By Annelise Hanshaw

There have been more bills prefiled for Missouri’s 2023 legislative session regarding transgender athletes than there are transgender athletes currently competing according to their identity in public schools.

Republican lawmakers in both the House and Senate have combined to file 10 bills seeking to restrict the ability of transgender minors to play in youth sports.

(Photo- Republican Sen. Mike Moon speaks on the Senate floor on Feb. 22, 2022- Madeline Carter/Missouri Independent).








In the 2021-2022 school year, only five transgender students applied to the Missouri State High School Athletics Association, or MSHSAA, to compete according to their gender identity.

Democrats and LGBTQ advocates say the flurry of bills is a discriminatory attack on an already marginalized community, motivated by partisan politics. GOP lawmakers pushing the bills, many of which are titled “Protect Women’s Sports Act,” say they are inspired by real concerns in their communities about fairness.

It’s a debate that played out repeatedly during the 2022 session, as Republicans pushed — and Democrats stalled — numerous bills targeting transgender youth. Ultimately, dysfunction in the Senate doomed their chances.

Sen. Mike Moon, R-Ash Grove and among the legislation’s most outspoken proponents, says he’s optimistic things will be different in 2023.

He points to Gov. Mike Parson’s support for his bill after the legislature adjourned in May.

“After the session ended, the governor’s office voiced support for the bill,” Moon said. “And whether that was the catalyst or not, I don’t know. But this year, now several [lmakers] have filed it, and perhaps that will create enough support so that it will pass.”

Meanwhile, opponents are gearing up for the fight.

“High school is hard enough. And it’s hard enough to fit in for students who already feel some kind of uniqueness or reason that they have to try a little bit harder to fit in with their peers,” said Shira Berkowitz, senior director of public policy and advocacy for PROMO, the state’s largest LGBTQ advocacy organization.

“They face higher rates of bullying. They face harassment and mistreatment sometimes, and the fact that they could be excluded from sports has a devastating effect, already in a vulnerable population,” Berkowitz said.

Patrick Sasser testified in front of a House committee in March in hopes his 11-year-old daughter could compete in sports according to her gender identity.

She has been denied access to some all-girls teams as she competes in multiple sports, he told The Independent in an interview. But her current teammates welcome her as just another athlete, there to kick the soccer ball and hopefully score a few points, he said.

But his daughter’s transition has not been without tears.








“The things that my 11-year-old has experienced in life, no kid should have to experience a lot of those things and be uncomfortable in their own body and have doubts or fears or anything like that. No kid should have to go through that,” he said. “That notion that someone would do that to dominate a sport, it’s just like, it’s crazy to me.”

"A good start"

MSHSAA’s application process for transgender athletes has been in place since 2012 and is more restrictive for transgender females who wish to compete on girls’ teams.

They can only compete according to their gender identity once they have been taking hormone-suppression medication for one year and must prove they are staying on their treatment to remain eligible. Since MSHSAA began this process in 2012, there have been 12 students who have applied and approved, said Jason West, MSHSAA’s communications director.

State Sen. Denny Hoskins, R-Warrensburg and a sponsor of one of the versions of the “Save Women’s Sports Act” bills, said he was not aware of MSHSAA’s regulations.

After being told the current rules for Missouri’s high school athletes, he called the process a “good start,” but said to have a real impact any policy needs to be in state law.

“We can do more and put something in state statute,” Hoskins said.

Eighteen states have banned transgender students from competing according to their gender identity since March 2020.

According to a Pew Research survey, 58% of Americans said they “favored” or “strongly favored” policies that limit transgender athletes’ participation to the sex they were assigned at birth.

“I have been contacted by parents who have daughters… They worked hard to develop the skills that they’ve attained and also to win over the scholarships they want. And they believe that having a [biological] male compete against them in competitive sport is unfair,” Moon said.

He said none of those families recounted a time their daughter competed against a transgender athlete.

Sasser believes GOP bills are “tapping into people’s fears and biases.”. “That’s why the legislators feel forced to take a stand on something that I don’t believe to be an issue,” he said.

Rep. Ian Mackey, D-Richmond Heights, believes opponents will be able to defeat the bill this year.

“There’s always going to be something more pressing… something that actually requires our attention that I hope will get in the way and that will cause us to do the jobs that we were sent there to do,” Mackey said, “which is bring resources back to our districts, improve the livelihood of our families and our communities, provide health care and education for Missourians.”

He believes most people that get involved in anti-trans legislation “don’t understand what it means to be transgender.”

Emotionally draining

Berkowitz said anti-trans legislation is emotionally damaging.

“The damage that these types of messages and bills perpetuates in our schools and in our classrooms and the physical activities that our kids participate in, does cause significant harm,” Berkowitz said.








The mental toll causes transgender athletes to opt out of sports they’d otherwise enjoy, Berkowitz said.

For Sasser and his family, who have repeatedly testified against this legislation, it is emotionally draining.

“It’s a really tough fight and a really tough thing to feel like I’m continually defending the identity of my own child – and the identity of other trans people in the state and around the nation.”

Hoskins and Moon acknowledged their legislation could have negative mental health effects on trans athletes.

“We want to be cognizant of all mental health concerns of any youth,” Hoskins said, “whether they are transgender or not transgender.”

The 10 bills filed by mid-December have various financial penalties for schools that allow transgender athletes to compete on the team opposite of their sex assigned at birth. Both Hoskins’ and Moon’s bills take away all legislative-directed funding until a school complies with their rules.

Monday, January 02, 2023

Springfield Regal Theater closing, Joplin Northstar 14 to remain open


Regal is closing its theater in Springfield, according to an announcement on Regal College Station's Facebook page, but the Regal Northstar 14 in Joplin will remain open

The decision was made by Regal's parent company, Cineworld Group, which filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in September.

The following statement was posted on the Springfield Regal's Facebook page:

Hello College Station Family,

We want to thank you for all of your support over the years as your downtown theatre. We have loved getting to know you and seeing the smiles on your faces as you experience the thrill of movies over the years. We are sad to announce that our doors will be closing permanently this next week with our last day of operation being 1/5/23. We invite you back for one last visit to say goodbye as we all move on to new things. If you are looking for another Regal to visit, we invite you to Regal Northstar in Joplin MO as the next closest theatre.

Best Wishes,
Your College Station Theatre

Former Joplin resident charged for role in January 6 insurrection

 

Former Joplin resident Dominic Box, currently a resident of Savannah, Georgia, was arrested December 15 on charges related to the January 6, 2021 insurrection at the U. S. Capitol Building.

Box, described in a recent Atlanta Journal-Constitution article as a "QAnon activist and conspiracy theorist" is charged with  "entering and remaining in a restricted building or grounds," "disorderly and disruptive conduct in a restricted building or grounds," " disorderly conduct in a Capitol Building," and "parading, demonstrating, or picketing in a Capitol Building," all misdemeanors.

According to the statement of facts filed in U. S. District Court for the District of Columbia, Box's participation in the insurrection was detailed in "open source photographs, posts and videos."

Box livestreamed his march to and into the Capitol Building on Facebook.

Box also received national media attention for his activities. 

BOX also elected to be interviewed in the HBO documentary, where he acknowledged his presence in and around U.S. Capitol on January 6, 2021, and, with a smile, stated as follows in his interview:

 “As I’m going up the scaffolding and getting to the steps, there was a kid who probably captured the emotions I was having . . . I was proud to see the American spirit that was on display."

The complete statement of facts can be found here.

The criminal complaint can be found here.


























Agenda posted for Jasper R-5 Board of Education meeting

 


















McDonald County R-1 hires current Jasper superintendent


(From the McDonald County R-1 School District)

A big announcement to kick off the new year for McDonald County Schools!
 
The McDonald County R-1 School Board of Education has chosen Dr. Eric Findley for the role of superintendent of schools.
 
Dr. Findley is currently superintendent at the Jasper R-5 School District in Jasper, Mo.







 
His career in education spans almost 25 years in schools across central Missouri, including roles as a physical education teacher and coach, guidance counselor, middle school and high school principal, and the superintendent position at High Point, Mo schools as well as his current position at Jasper R-5 Schools.

To find out more information about him, visit the news section of our website at mcdonaldr1.net.
He replaces Dr. Mark Stanton who will retire at the end of the 2022-2023 school year.

Dr. Findley’s first day on the job at McDonald County Schools will be July 1, 2023.