Sunday, January 22, 2006

The evils of blogging

First, to correct the outlandish rumors that have been circulating in the Diamond area.
It is not true that a priest was called in to perform exorcisms on five Diamond High School students, even though apparently the administration in the R-4 School District must believe that anyone who blogs has been possessed by the devil (and considering the fun I have had at their expense, that belief might be understandable).
Last week, five students were called into the principal's office and charged with violating the district's technology policy. And, in fact, they did. Thank God, Superintendent Mark Mayo and the other school officials don't have lethal injection as one of the punishments at their disposal or it might be curtains for my former students, including Michelle Nickolaisen. They weren't looking at pornography; they weren't playing ultra-violent games; they weren't even indulging in on-line gambling (though from what I hear, gambling is not considered to be a sin by some of those in the administration).
Apparently, they were reading blogs, getting around the blocks set up by the district's technology coordinator. I doubt if The Turner Report was one of those blogs, though I am sure it was one of the reasons why the blocks were put in place.
Even worse, Michelle actually did some blogging.
On her blog, Victim of Reality, she detailed her conversation with the high school principal:

"Have you done anything that violates the technology user agreement?"
"Yeah, I used a website to go around the school blocks and look at some blogs, that in my opinion didn't contain any inappropriate for school material."
"Did you make any posts on your blog?"
*thought - oops, maybe this isn't all that simple*
"Yes, I did."
"Did you say anything bad about the school or its teachers?"
"Yeah."
"How would you like it if someone said things like that about you?"
"I don't care."
"Well, Michelle, if you have a problem with this school or a teacher here, you should tell me about it rather than posting it on a website. You know that's defamation of character, right?"
"Saying bad things about someone?"
"Yes, that teacher - and I haven't told her - could sue if you she wanted. I'm not threatening to sue you, but in the real world[how I love it when they use that phrase] you could get hauled off in handcuffs for something like that. Does your mother know that you say things like this, and use profanity in your blog?"
"My mom reads my blog."
"Do you really think the class is that bad?"
"Yes, I do."
"Is it so bad as to be 'killing brain cells'?"
"Yes."
"Then you need to tell me about it instead of posting it behind her back. How would you feel if someone did that to you?"
"I don't care."
"Well someday you will! This isn't a bad school..."


When I read Michelle's account, I thought, "Wow, she must have said something really bad." So I read that post. I will admit what she said would probably not make the teacher happy, but opinion is protected by the First Amendment, something that the administration at Diamond seems to forget about. Also, while I am not thrilled with the word, I was unaware that "crap" is considered to be profanity. If she violated their rules, then she will have to take the punishment, no matter how asinine the rules are, but attempting to browbeat and threaten students by stretching the truth about their rights is unforgivable.

It also appears, though the principal denied it when she talked with Michelle's mother, according to the blog, that Michelle was warned about further critical blogging...even if she does it from home.

I do not know this principal; I do not want to know this principal. However, I do know Michelle Nickolaisen. She will not suffer fools or bullies and she tells the truth.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

While blogs can be good, you might point out to your students that many employers (or hr people) are "googling" names to see if prospective applicants have blogs. Negative blogs have been used to discredit writers, and in turn, keep them from getting jobs. This may be the case for college-aged students, but alas, even middle school and high school blogers grow up.

Anonymous said...

This was even discussed in a local Sunday School class yesterday. Don't go after the kids doing drugs and things- go after the smart ones that might know more than the teachers.

Anonymous said...

Okay does the r-8 district go by that too. or just that district??Im pretty sure that is a bunch of bull.Getting in trouble for speaking your mind.

Anonymous said...

Diamond isn't the only local school district that has The Turner Report blocked on school computers.

Randy said...

I am curious. What school districts are we talking about and is it The Turner Report that is blocked or just blogs in general?

Anonymous said...

Well, I can tell you about the students in question, their blogs could not be discovered by googling their names, personality traits, school, or anything of a personal nature. I know several of these students well, and when they changed their blogs I could not find them by googling. I found their sites the same way the school did, by looking at history on the network, at my house. Oh, another novel approach that worked for me was to ask my daughter for the URL's. Actually my daughter has blogged since about 7th grade and I don't think you can pull up any of that info. And if you must know, several of Michelle's family members read her blog. Her grandmother, aunts, and uncles sometimes check in as a way to keep in touch, and remember what it is like to be seventeen.

Anonymous said...

Actually Mom, a very short google search of your daughter's name led me to a host of sites her name appear on, including this site, and one she apparently built for a Diamond wrestling program.

By coming to this site, I could see each time Randy mentioned her by name, and the name of her blog. Finding the link then, was as simple as clicking on Randy's links either in the blog text or the link to the side of the page (with other web sites).

While I wasn't directly talking about your daughter's site, my point is this...what you write now, either in print media or blogs, can come back to haunt you later.

It's just something, Randy's students should begin to think about, because frankly, my guess is none of them have not thougtht past graduation, let alone college.

Yes, teen blogs are a good way to keep in touch with family and friends, but sometimes a bit of teenage angst can go a long way.